Latest article: Which decisions matter before root canal treatment in a patient with diabetes?

Moving to single-visit treatment

What are your indications for single-visit treatment? In which cases would you recommend it?

Translated version of the Turkish original

For colleagues beginning single-visit treatment, I suggest starting with vital teeth with simple anatomy, a single root and a single canal, then progressing with experience to multirooted vital teeth, suitable necrotic teeth and selected retreatment cases. I regard this sequence as an approach that makes it easier to gain clinical experience.

For me, the main criterion is whether all necessary stages can be completed to an adequate standard in the same visit. Merely being able to remove the pulp is insufficient: adequate chemomechanical preparation and irrigation of every canal under rubber dam isolation, drying of the canals and sufficient time for appropriate obturation are needed. [1]

Regarding success, the 2022 Cochrane review found no significant difference between single- and multiple-visit treatment in radiographic failure at a minimum of one year. However, the absence of a statistically significant difference does not establish that the approaches are definitely equivalent in every clinical situation. [2]

The ESE's 2023 guideline recommends single-visit treatment without interappointment calcium hydroxide in permanent teeth with asymptomatic apical periodontitis when adequate clinical procedures have been completed. Necrosis or a periapical lesion alone therefore does not make multiple visits mandatory. The evidence underlying this recommendation cannot be directly generalised to acute apical periodontitis. [3]

For teeth with a sinus tract, I also consider prognosis. In the prospective study by Ng and colleagues, complete periapical healing at root level was reported in 85% of primary treatments without a sinus tract and 66.7% with one; for retreatment the respective figures were 82.4% and 60.3%. These correspond to absolute differences of approximately 18–22 percentage points. A sinus tract was associated with lower healing rates even after other prognostic variables were taken into account. [4]

For this reason, particularly in teeth with a sinus tract and longstanding infection, I more often choose interappointment calcium hydroxide and multiple visits to provide an additional antibacterial effect after chemomechanical preparation and irrigation. My rationale is to support infection control in cases with a potentially poorer prognosis. However, Ng and colleagues' study was prognostic; it does not directly show that multiple visits eliminate this difference in success in teeth with sinus tracts. [4]

Clinical studies show that calcium hydroxide can provide an additional effect against bacteria remaining after preparation. Nevertheless, this additional antibacterial effect is not consistent across all studies; one cannot assume that the canal becomes sterile or that clinical success necessarily improves. An interappointment dressing does not replace adequate preparation and irrigation. [1,5,6]

The timing of assessment also matters for postoperative pain. The Cochrane review found a higher proportion of patients reporting pain within one week of the first intervention in the single-visit group, but no clear difference during the first 72 hours after obturation. It is therefore inappropriate to predict less or more pain solely from the number of visits. [2]

Finally, if I cannot dry the canal with paper points because of persistent exudate, pus or uncontrolled bleeding after removing the irrigant, I do not obturate at that visit. I assess the cause and proceed to another visit with appropriate interim treatment and a well-sealed temporary restoration. I choose single-visit treatment when the necessary cleaning and disinfection can be completed and the canal system can be made suitable for obturation. [1]

Author of the original answer: Doç. Dr. İsmail Davut Çapar

Medical review of the Turkish original:

Turkish answer published on this website:

Translation published:

The review date refers to the Turkish original; it does not indicate a separate medical review of the translation.

References